Choir of New College, Oxford, conducted by Robert Quinney
80:38
Linn Records
CKD793
We are already indebted to New College Choir under Robert Quinney for outstanding discs of Tudor luminaries William Mundy and John Sheppard. Now we are presented with a recording of Tallis’s most substantial work besides Spem in alium, plus a good handful of his Latin pieces. We are not overburdened with recordings of the great seven-part mass, not least because of its dimensions but also because most of the Credo no longer survives. Most of these recordings are by mixed adult chamber choirs, so a version by the sort of ecclesiastical male choir for whom Tallis composed the mass provides something different. The motets and responsories are already available in other versions, some of them amply so, but more of this shortly.
The mass is quite simply a magnificent work. There is no documentary evidence pointing to when or why it was composed, but stylistically it seems to date from the reign of Mary I, who revived Roman Catholic ritual after the hardline Protestantism of her predecessor and half-brother Edward VI. It has been suggested that this mass was composed for the visit of her husband Philip II, King of Spain, and his Capilla Flamenca, with the intention that the two choirs should combine to perform it. Certainly it is one of Tallis’s most Flemish works, its almost continuous seven-part texture evoking echoes of Gombert. New College sound throughout the recording like the outstanding ecclesiastical choir which they are, singing liturgical music as if in divine service. Nearest to heaven is the Hosanna in the Sanctus, one of even Tallis’s most inspired passages, performed accordingly.
With one exception, all other versions currently available are by the half dozen finest chamber choirs. Of these versions, the best in my opinion remains the earliest, made originally in 1977 and still available today: besides capturing the ethos of a sacred as distinct from a secular performance, The Clerkes of Oxenford under David Wulstan create a hypnotic spirituality, most notably in the Agnus with a pensive, preoccupied plea for peace, expressed partly through an insistent but gentle undulating theme which was subsequently borrowed by Byrd for the second of his two In nomines in four parts. The Clerkes’ is also the only recording to include what can be salvaged of the Credo: just the final 1’22 but, being Tallis, worth salvaging.
The exception mentioned above is a thoroughly recommendable version by another ecclesiastical choir, the Gentlemen of the Chapel Royal, Hampton Court, with the six regular Gentlemen augmented by the eight supernumeraries to provide a performance of dignity, depth and clarity.
All of the Latin works have many alternative recordings by a variety of choirs and ensembles. Perhaps the most elusive, or least familiar, of the pieces is Homo quidem, and this is the best performance of all the shorter works, its striking final cadence (which, pleasingly, has liturgically to be repeated a few times) given with a thrilling flourish. A number of the motets were not envisaged by Tallis for liturgical performance but were published in the Cantiones sacrae of 1575 jointly with his pupil and friend Byrd, for domestic consumption. While New College deal expansively with the dissonances and false relations in the works that survive in manuscripts intended for the liturgy, with substantial numbers of singers in an ecclesiastical acoustic they sometimes do not quite clinch these cadences in the 1575 pieces such as those concluding O nata lux and In manus tuas which are better suited to performances by ensembles with one or two singers to a part. But this is a small reservation compared to the choir’s masterful interpretation of Tallis’s wonderful mass.
Richard Turbet